Manager Call 2016-11-16
From GO Wiki
Agenda: Kimberly Van Auken
Minutes: Moni Munoz-Torres
Present: Paul, Kimberly, Suzi, Huaiyu, David H, Chris, Melanie, Moni, Paola.
- This issue is wrt a response to a request from Peter Karp to list his group's annotation tool on the GO website.
- What should be listed on the website? See http://geneontology.org/faq/where-can-i-find-software-allow-me-make-or-edit-go-annotations
- The current FAQ on this only specifically mentions CANTO: http://geneontology.org/faq/where-can-i-find-software-allow-me-make-or-edit-go-annotations
- For the GO-help issue, see http://jira.geneontology.org/browse/GO-1379 - For historical context, this FAQ was ported over from the old website and last updated on October 14 of 2014. - The answer we should add to this FAQ is that curators can use Noctua. Given that there is not yet a system / plan in place to open Noctua for the public to contribute annotations, in the mean time we can list Canto, Cacao, Protein2GO, and Pathway Tools (http://pathwaytools.com/) - Paul: Add comments informing curators that if you have a small number of annotations, you can send them to us, see "here". If you want to start a new effort, let us know “here”. - Moni: Let’s send them through the decision tree we created and added to the 'Contributing to GO' page! This will allow them to contribute their annotations in the most efficient way. ToDo: Send Paul contact info for Pathway Tools to be added to registry at Elixir (Melanie did this? MC: yes, done :)).
- Note that we also do mention other tools on our FAQ page for performing enrichment analyses for species not included in the drop-down list on the website
- Proposal (Paola): general recommendation for endorsing software for use of GOC resources should be that at least one of the members of GOC has used it. - ToDo: Make the FAQ (http://geneontology.org/faq/how-can-i-do-term-enrichment-analysis-species-not-present-list-amigo) match what’s on the Enrichment Analysis Help Page at http://geneontology.org/page/go-enrichment-analysis
- From Minutes of last call?
- Genomespace looks a bit too much like an environment in which tools can be linked rather than a registry per se.
- We propose to use the Elixir registry assuming we can punctually request to add content. (Melanie sent email to Jon) If it's only a handful of request we can add on a case by case, if it's more than that we can revisit this issue.
2016 Year-End Progress Reports
- Google docs
- Wiki pages
- ToDo: create Google Doc per institution, and also a separate document where all efforts will be combined and summarized. - As we ask institutions to prepare their individual documents, ask them to follow a template. Suzi will prepare the templates and add them to this directory: https://drive.google.com/drive/u/1/folders/0B8kRPmmvPJU3SzNuZ0YzVVJEOWc
Food for thought
- What is the biggest challenge for ontology development?
- What is the biggest challenge for annotation?
- What tool is most urgently needed?
- How can we be consumers and users of GO ourselves? (eat our own dog food?)
- Suzi: suggestion to set up main and large-scope goals for the year. Addressing the questions in the agenda. Suzi requests that everyone thinks of these questions. - Paul suggests that these goals should be organized on the GOC Projects page at https://github.com/orgs/geneontology/projects