Difference between revisions of "AmiGO-chat-5June07"

From GO Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(New page: <font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:38:13 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> shall we get started?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:38:21 A...)
 
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
[[Category:AmiGO working group]]
 
<font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:38:13 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> shall we get started?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:38:21 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> sorry--new client</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:38:44 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> yes</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:39:39 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> we were going to review the download options at biomart, NCBI etc</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:40:12 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> who wants to go first?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:40:17 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I can go first</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:40:22 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Go for it Ben</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:40:46 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> well  - I looked at the Biomart 0.5 implementation at EBI</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:41:17 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> this querying system allows you to basically construct your own &quot;excel&quot; table from various columns from various databases.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:41:33 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> There are probably millions of possible outputs.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:42:12 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> Basically  you go through some javascript forms to set up the columns you want in your output, then you construct &quot;filters&quot; which limit the rows (so you don't get back the whole genome or whatever)</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:42:30 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> How intuitive and easy are those forms?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:42:39 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> they suck</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:42:48 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> ho</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:42:56 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> but no fault of design  - it's just an impossible task</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:43:05 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I mean there are HUNDREDS of columns</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:43:11 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> but we won't have that problem</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:43:32 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> besides the volume, were there any other problems?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:43:37 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I think for amigo purposes, we can probably just ship some set of columns.  The filtering system is pretty good.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:43:51 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> No, I actualy like it for what it does</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:44:01 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> other cool things:</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:44:22 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> &quot;count&quot; button - so when you've assembled a query and possibly filters you can see how many rows you get back.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:44:40 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> Easy to get varaious options (HTML, CSV, TSV, XSL, XML)</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:44:45 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> obv. I meant various</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:45:05 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> can export to File, browser, or compressed file</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:45:25 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> The ability to conjoin with other databases is pretty cool - but I wouldn't think of implementing this for us.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:46:27 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> you mean other databases like Taxon, OMIM, Pubmed</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:46:28 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> oh, and they have a web service and a GUI button to ship you the XML you need to re-fetch the same query.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:46:53 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> no, sorry - I didn't explain scope.  Biomart generally searches geneomes - human, rat, etc.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:47:04 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> if you link databases, you can combine queries.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:47:17 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> genome _databases_</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:47:30 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I see</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(08:47:56 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> I've used Biomart before, and although it's not immediately intutitive, it is very cool because it's so configurable</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:48:14 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> how was the learning curve?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(08:48:36 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> not too bad - one session and I had a fairly good idea how to use</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(08:48:37 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> it</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:48:52 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> it's irrelvant - right?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:49:09 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> we are not going to actually USE biomart, just rip off it's interfaces (if we like them)</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:49:24 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> thus the learning curve</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:49:45 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> where stuff is, how to get to things</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(08:49:52 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> yeah, i think the hardest thing was understanding what all the labels meant but I think if we label things on the interface appropriately, this should be easier.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:50:02 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> even to get the general idea of what it can do</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(08:50:42 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> I agree with Eurie - it's figuring out what data are in the different columns that makes it tricky</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(08:51:00 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> if we can make that intuitive we'd be laughing</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:51:26 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I think we would be better served by giving fewer options and just defaulting the output to more columsn</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(08:51:47 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> yeah - our database is much simpler so we could do that</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(08:52:13 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> Also, alluding to the wizard vs. single page discussion over email, the filtering options (which data you want to restrict by) are all on one page.  which helps you see everything at once.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:52:20 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> biomart is like that because it has to be generic - you can interface any database to it, so obviuosly it doesn't know what colunms to show.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:52:35 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> although in principal you could &quot;hardwire&quot; biomart ... but I digress</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(08:53:32 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> I think the older biomart implementation was a wizard -  multi page step through.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(08:54:29 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> the ideal implementation would be something which allowed the more advanced users to configure the results to their liking, but which wouldn't alienate newbies by being too complex</font><br><font size="2">(08:54:29 AM) </font><b><font size="3">rama left the room (quit: Read error: Connection reset by peer).</font></b><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(08:55:29 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> oops, we lost our chair</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(08:55:51 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> perhaps the default should be simple, so that people aren't overwhelmed by huge amounts of data</font><br><font size="2">(08:56:01 AM) </font><b><font size="3">rama [<i>rama@c-24-7-125-169.hsd1.ca.comcast.net</i>] entered the room.</font></b><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:56:11 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> sorry, i got disconnected</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:56:22 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I guess to break it down:</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:56:42 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> row selection good.  column selection bad.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:56:55 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Can somebody save the transcript for me ( I lost parts of it).</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:57:02 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> maybe in blocks it's OK -</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:57:21 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> we assume people want gene_products -&gt; associations</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(08:57:31 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> for example, I think that the a</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(08:57:35 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> ooops, sorry</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:57:44 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> +/- species +/- evidence (?!?) +/- references</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:57:50 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> (rama--I'll save and send what I have)</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:57:59 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> oh, we should also move on to another interface</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:58:10 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I was just about to say that Ben</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:58:19 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Donghui, do you want to go?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(08:58:37 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> sure</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(08:59:16 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> just a second</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:00:16 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/batchentrez.cgi?db=Nucleotide">http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/batchentrez.cgi?db=Nucleotide</a> </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:00:32 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> first, The Batch Search has now been combined with the ?regular? Entrez Search: ?You will need Batch Entrez now only to upload a file of GI or accession numbers for an Entrez search. You can do all other large searches directly within Entrez.? </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:01:22 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> I don't know exactly how to do a large search directly within entrez</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:01:34 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> So i tried the Batch search</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:02:07 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> The nicest part of Entrez is its result display: very flexible.  You can filter the results in all kinds of ways. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:02:07 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> You can choose to display different parts of the gene information: Brief, Summary, Sequence in different format etc. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:02:07 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> You can specify the number of hits to display per page as well as sort results accession and Taxonomy ID. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:02:07 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> It allows user to send the result to various destinations: as txt, as a file, printer or clipboard. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:03:11 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> the other nice feature is that Entrez allows users to save search history for 8 hrs, which is useful</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:04:55 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> if you want to try the search you can put the following GI/accession numbers into a txt file:</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:00 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> The nicest part of Entrez is its result display: very flexible.  You can filter the results in all kinds of ways. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:00 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> You can choose to display different parts of the gene information: Brief, Summary, Sequence in different format etc. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:00 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> You can specify the number of hits to display per page as well as sort results accession and Taxonomy ID. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:00 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> It allows user to send the result to various destinations: as txt, as a file, printer or clipboard. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:04 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> sorry</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:13 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> AL436771 </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:14 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> AL423804 </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:14 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> AL422882 </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:14 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> CZ193470 </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:14 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> DQ052056 </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:16 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> DQ052055 </font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:06:54 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> are there links and tools relevant to your search results?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:07:26 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> what do you mean by tools?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:07:42 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> for example ClustalW to see alignment?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:08:09 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> I did not see that</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:08:38 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> I couldn't get it to work - says 'No query #1 in history for database nucleotide'</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:09:09 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> that's strange, it happened to me too.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:10:39 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> anyone else get it to work?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:10:57 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Donghui, for batch download do you always need GI/accession #s or gene names will work?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:13:09 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I am going to move on</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:13:14 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> to SRS</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:13:18 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> yes, that's pain</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:13:49 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> the file can only contain GI or accession numbers, I have tried these numbers when I tested it</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:14:30 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> thanks DOnghui. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:14:43 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> if I want to retrieve sequences for Arabidopsis genes and I only know the Arabidopsis locus identifier, these identifiers have to be converted to GI or accerssion numbers first</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:15:44 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> that is a pain. </font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:16:03 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> the take home is we can look at their results page for display ideas</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:16:05 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> ?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:16:37 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> <a href="http://srs.ebi.ac.uk/">http://srs.ebi.ac.uk/</a></font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:16:51 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Anybody, any questions on NCBI?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:17:52 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Okay...moving on. Please visit SRS at the above URL</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:18:43 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Few things I liked- They have a whole list of Databases that one can choose from. They include Pubmed, Taxon, etc (databases are not limited to what is maintained at EBI)</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:19:57 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> 2) Views- you can control what you want to see, what you want hyperlinked. For example, for a pubmed citation, you can view only the PMID and not the other details. </font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:20:11 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> 3) Tools relevant to your search results</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:20:52 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> If you have a list of proteins as output, it suggests tools that can be used to analyze that list further. CLustalW for example. They have a whole suite of tools</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:21:41 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> 4) All your queries are saved in the 'Projects' link on the top tool bar.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:22:50 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> First time I saw the interface it was overwhelming (like Biomart), but then it has lots of features</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(09:23:10 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> Rama, how long are your queries saved?  Just for that session?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:23:29 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> i think just for that session. </font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:24:34 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> it is more than a tool for downloading</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:25:06 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I meant, it has more utilities than just downloading options</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:25:31 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I am not sure if they store all the Pubmed data inhouse or if it is accessed on the fly</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:25:50 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> I like their 'quick search' page - the library page is a bit off-putting</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:26:11 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> (PubMed is kept in-house btw)</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:26:19 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Jane, I totally agree with you. Everything is overwhelming</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:27:03 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> one needs to get familiar with the system</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:27:08 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> it's better than it used to be - last time i used it you went straight to that library page</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:27:30 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> if you're not familiar with what's in what database, you don't have a clue</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:27:46 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> absolutely. </font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:28:10 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I am familiar with only few of the DBs listed on that page</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:29:03 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> I've always found it too intimidating to use!</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:29:11 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> in the Pathways section for example, I had no idea what Ureaction Lreaction etc., meant</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:29:49 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I agree it is intimidating. But I think there are some features that we might want to copy</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:30:41 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> I don't think AmiGO could ever be that intimidating as we're only covering one database - they have so many databases to query that if you don't know what you're looking for, it's just overwhelming</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:30:42 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> As I said earlier, it is just not a tool for downloading. It aims to be comprehensive and take an user through a workflow</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:31:22 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I just realized it is almost 930AM</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:31:26 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> I got the NCBI search to work with the same file, do we still have time to give it try after the SRS? We need to change the database from Nucleotide to GSS.  The same file will work.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:32:05 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> hmmm...I am afraid we need to wrap up things soon.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:32:20 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Any questions so far?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:32:37 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> maybe email the file donghui and we can run it on our own?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:32:43 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> OK, here is the result page:</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:32:45 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> does anyone need to run off? otherwise I reckon keep going a bit longer as it's interesting to see the + / - points of these tools</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:32:46 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?WebEnv=0G02PfWyn2X5dk95ESMxI7GbRWFFh0iBk3fYAa8XkrrBMEp9kxYBdeeKCe2SEtZ7z2t7sfKTIA4AY%40D4497E80665820A0_0000SID&WebEnvRq=1&query_key=17&cmd=HistorySearch&db=nucgss">http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?WebEnv=0G02PfWyn2X5dk95ESMxI7GbRWFFh0iBk3fYAa8XkrrBMEp9kxYBdeeKCe2SEtZ7z2t7sfKTIA4AY%40D4497E80665820A0_0000SID&amp;WebEnvRq=1&amp;query_key=17&amp;cmd=HistorySearch&amp;db=nucgss</a></font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:32:48 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Sure. good idea Ben</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:33:24 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I am fine to continue</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(09:33:54 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> i'm not going anywhere</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:34:11 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> me too</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:34:14 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Please speak up if you *have to go*</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:34:28 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> alright, let's go back to NCBI for a few min</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:34:34 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> okay</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:34:50 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> the above link will direct you to the results page</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:34:55 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> I like the 'sort by' and 'send to' pull-down menus</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:35:51 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I must leave in 15-20 mins or so.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:35:58 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> The NCBI interface is very simple, however, like what happended, the query file has to be properly formatted (with GI or accession numeners0, which is not very flexible</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:36:03 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> but I do like to results page</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:36:17 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> Click the Display button</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:36:20 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I love the results page. It is simple</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:36:50 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> the results page is great, that's the nicest part of Entrez</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:37:12 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> so results page good, configurability bad</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:37:16 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I don't really care for it</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:38:55 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> the results page... that is.  It's fine I guess</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:40:03 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> any other comments?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(09:40:06 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> The one that frustrates me is that once you've selected an alternate display on the pull-down, it's not clear how to get back to your original results page.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(09:40:51 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> And the pull-down options on other displays isn't consistent</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:41:17 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> I agree with Eurie on the alt displays</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(09:41:18 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> for example, you don't get all the same options if you've selected &quot;graph&quot;</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:41:38 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> you are right, they are not consistent</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:41:44 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> it's a bit buggy too - keeps giving me error messages</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:41:58 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> I also don't like the way that there's no 'confirm', it just automatically switches displays - that's annoying if you pick the wrong one</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(09:42:15 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> maybe we've confused the crap out of because we've got ip addresses around the world hitting the same page.  ;)</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:42:31 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> haha</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(09:43:24 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> but one principle that i like in general is if there are multiple pages or views or lots of categories, how do i get to a previous one without hitting the back button.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:43:25 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> I actually like the No Confirm, you don't have to do that extra click</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:45:52 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> any more comments on NCBI?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:46:58 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> any questions on SRS?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:47:52 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> could I ask a couple of general questions if the summaries are finished?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:48:05 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Go on GWG</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:48:19 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> these are for all the people who've looked at tools</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:48:58 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> did you need to have a clear goal in mind and background knowledge of the data source to be able to use the tool effectively?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:50:16 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> no</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:50:32 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> although &quot;what is effective&quot;</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:50:49 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> I guess 'to be able to use the tool' would be better</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:50:53 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I had some goal in mind I would say</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:51:03 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> otherwise I couldn't evaluate the results</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:51:29 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> were there specific features that made the tool easier to use?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:51:40 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I liked &quot;count&quot; button</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:52:02 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> nothing in particular for SRS</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:52:06 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> and conversely, things that made it hard to use?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:52:12 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> too many options</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:52:26 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> SRS suffers from data overload</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:52:30 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> ok, I gotta go</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:52:40 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> thanks Ben!</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:52:41 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> have to know which specific database to search</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:52:44 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> see you. thanks Ben</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:52:55 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> shouldn't be a problem for amigo</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:53:03 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> I have to go too</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:53:13 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> shall we wrap up?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:53:20 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> yup, sounds good</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:53:29 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> before I finish, somebody please save the transcript</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(09:53:40 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> saved</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:53:50 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I guess, I don't have any action items</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:54:12 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> quick! Let's think of some action items for Rama!</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:54:30 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> We all like some options in all these sites. Seems like Biomart is very flexible and usable.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:54:39 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> NCBI has good results display</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:55:20 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> SRS kind of integrates tools to the data and tries to offer a complete utility</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:55:34 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Quick action items?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:56:28 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3">  I don't know that there are any really...</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(09:56:34 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> if we missed anything, we could finish over email</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:56:44 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> okay. good. see you all in 2 weeks</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:56:54 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> see you then!</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:56:57 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Seth, please email transcript to the WG</font><br><font size="2">(09:56:57 AM) </font><b><font size="3">gwg left the room (quit: Quit: Goodbye cruel world!).</font></b><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:56:58 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> thanks</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(09:57:08 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> no problem--bye</font>
 
<font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:38:13 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> shall we get started?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:38:21 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> sorry--new client</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:38:44 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> yes</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:39:39 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> we were going to review the download options at biomart, NCBI etc</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:40:12 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> who wants to go first?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:40:17 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I can go first</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:40:22 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Go for it Ben</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:40:46 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> well  - I looked at the Biomart 0.5 implementation at EBI</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:41:17 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> this querying system allows you to basically construct your own &quot;excel&quot; table from various columns from various databases.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:41:33 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> There are probably millions of possible outputs.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:42:12 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> Basically  you go through some javascript forms to set up the columns you want in your output, then you construct &quot;filters&quot; which limit the rows (so you don't get back the whole genome or whatever)</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:42:30 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> How intuitive and easy are those forms?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:42:39 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> they suck</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:42:48 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> ho</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:42:56 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> but no fault of design  - it's just an impossible task</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:43:05 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I mean there are HUNDREDS of columns</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:43:11 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> but we won't have that problem</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:43:32 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> besides the volume, were there any other problems?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:43:37 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I think for amigo purposes, we can probably just ship some set of columns.  The filtering system is pretty good.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:43:51 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> No, I actualy like it for what it does</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:44:01 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> other cool things:</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:44:22 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> &quot;count&quot; button - so when you've assembled a query and possibly filters you can see how many rows you get back.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:44:40 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> Easy to get varaious options (HTML, CSV, TSV, XSL, XML)</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:44:45 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> obv. I meant various</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:45:05 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> can export to File, browser, or compressed file</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:45:25 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> The ability to conjoin with other databases is pretty cool - but I wouldn't think of implementing this for us.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:46:27 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> you mean other databases like Taxon, OMIM, Pubmed</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:46:28 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> oh, and they have a web service and a GUI button to ship you the XML you need to re-fetch the same query.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:46:53 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> no, sorry - I didn't explain scope.  Biomart generally searches geneomes - human, rat, etc.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:47:04 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> if you link databases, you can combine queries.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:47:17 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> genome _databases_</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:47:30 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I see</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(08:47:56 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> I've used Biomart before, and although it's not immediately intutitive, it is very cool because it's so configurable</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:48:14 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> how was the learning curve?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(08:48:36 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> not too bad - one session and I had a fairly good idea how to use</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(08:48:37 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> it</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:48:52 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> it's irrelvant - right?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:49:09 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> we are not going to actually USE biomart, just rip off it's interfaces (if we like them)</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:49:24 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> thus the learning curve</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:49:45 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> where stuff is, how to get to things</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(08:49:52 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> yeah, i think the hardest thing was understanding what all the labels meant but I think if we label things on the interface appropriately, this should be easier.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:50:02 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> even to get the general idea of what it can do</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(08:50:42 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> I agree with Eurie - it's figuring out what data are in the different columns that makes it tricky</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(08:51:00 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> if we can make that intuitive we'd be laughing</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:51:26 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I think we would be better served by giving fewer options and just defaulting the output to more columsn</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(08:51:47 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> yeah - our database is much simpler so we could do that</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(08:52:13 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> Also, alluding to the wizard vs. single page discussion over email, the filtering options (which data you want to restrict by) are all on one page.  which helps you see everything at once.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:52:20 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> biomart is like that because it has to be generic - you can interface any database to it, so obviuosly it doesn't know what colunms to show.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:52:35 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> although in principal you could &quot;hardwire&quot; biomart ... but I digress</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(08:53:32 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> I think the older biomart implementation was a wizard -  multi page step through.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(08:54:29 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> the ideal implementation would be something which allowed the more advanced users to configure the results to their liking, but which wouldn't alienate newbies by being too complex</font><br><font size="2">(08:54:29 AM) </font><b><font size="3">rama left the room (quit: Read error: Connection reset by peer).</font></b><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(08:55:29 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> oops, we lost our chair</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(08:55:51 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> perhaps the default should be simple, so that people aren't overwhelmed by huge amounts of data</font><br><font size="2">(08:56:01 AM) </font><b><font size="3">rama [<i>rama@c-24-7-125-169.hsd1.ca.comcast.net</i>] entered the room.</font></b><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:56:11 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> sorry, i got disconnected</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:56:22 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I guess to break it down:</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:56:42 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> row selection good.  column selection bad.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:56:55 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Can somebody save the transcript for me ( I lost parts of it).</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:57:02 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> maybe in blocks it's OK -</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:57:21 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> we assume people want gene_products -&gt; associations</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(08:57:31 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> for example, I think that the a</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(08:57:35 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> ooops, sorry</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:57:44 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> +/- species +/- evidence (?!?) +/- references</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(08:57:50 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> (rama--I'll save and send what I have)</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(08:57:59 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> oh, we should also move on to another interface</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:58:10 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I was just about to say that Ben</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(08:58:19 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Donghui, do you want to go?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(08:58:37 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> sure</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(08:59:16 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> just a second</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:00:16 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/batchentrez.cgi?db=Nucleotide">http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/batchentrez.cgi?db=Nucleotide</a> </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:00:32 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> first, The Batch Search has now been combined with the ?regular? Entrez Search: ?You will need Batch Entrez now only to upload a file of GI or accession numbers for an Entrez search. You can do all other large searches directly within Entrez.? </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:01:22 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> I don't know exactly how to do a large search directly within entrez</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:01:34 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> So i tried the Batch search</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:02:07 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> The nicest part of Entrez is its result display: very flexible.  You can filter the results in all kinds of ways. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:02:07 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> You can choose to display different parts of the gene information: Brief, Summary, Sequence in different format etc. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:02:07 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> You can specify the number of hits to display per page as well as sort results accession and Taxonomy ID. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:02:07 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> It allows user to send the result to various destinations: as txt, as a file, printer or clipboard. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:03:11 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> the other nice feature is that Entrez allows users to save search history for 8 hrs, which is useful</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:04:55 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> if you want to try the search you can put the following GI/accession numbers into a txt file:</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:00 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> The nicest part of Entrez is its result display: very flexible.  You can filter the results in all kinds of ways. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:00 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> You can choose to display different parts of the gene information: Brief, Summary, Sequence in different format etc. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:00 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> You can specify the number of hits to display per page as well as sort results accession and Taxonomy ID. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:00 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> It allows user to send the result to various destinations: as txt, as a file, printer or clipboard. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:04 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> sorry</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:13 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> AL436771 </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:14 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> AL423804 </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:14 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> AL422882 </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:14 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> CZ193470 </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:14 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> DQ052056 </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:05:16 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> DQ052055 </font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:06:54 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> are there links and tools relevant to your search results?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:07:26 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> what do you mean by tools?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:07:42 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> for example ClustalW to see alignment?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:08:09 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> I did not see that</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:08:38 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> I couldn't get it to work - says 'No query #1 in history for database nucleotide'</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:09:09 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> that's strange, it happened to me too.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:10:39 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> anyone else get it to work?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:10:57 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Donghui, for batch download do you always need GI/accession #s or gene names will work?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:13:09 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I am going to move on</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:13:14 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> to SRS</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:13:18 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> yes, that's pain</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:13:49 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> the file can only contain GI or accession numbers, I have tried these numbers when I tested it</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:14:30 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> thanks DOnghui. </font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:14:43 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> if I want to retrieve sequences for Arabidopsis genes and I only know the Arabidopsis locus identifier, these identifiers have to be converted to GI or accerssion numbers first</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:15:44 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> that is a pain. </font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:16:03 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> the take home is we can look at their results page for display ideas</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:16:05 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> ?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:16:37 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> <a href="http://srs.ebi.ac.uk/">http://srs.ebi.ac.uk/</a></font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:16:51 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Anybody, any questions on NCBI?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:17:52 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Okay...moving on. Please visit SRS at the above URL</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:18:43 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Few things I liked- They have a whole list of Databases that one can choose from. They include Pubmed, Taxon, etc (databases are not limited to what is maintained at EBI)</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:19:57 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> 2) Views- you can control what you want to see, what you want hyperlinked. For example, for a pubmed citation, you can view only the PMID and not the other details. </font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:20:11 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> 3) Tools relevant to your search results</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:20:52 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> If you have a list of proteins as output, it suggests tools that can be used to analyze that list further. CLustalW for example. They have a whole suite of tools</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:21:41 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> 4) All your queries are saved in the 'Projects' link on the top tool bar.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:22:50 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> First time I saw the interface it was overwhelming (like Biomart), but then it has lots of features</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(09:23:10 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> Rama, how long are your queries saved?  Just for that session?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:23:29 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> i think just for that session. </font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:24:34 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> it is more than a tool for downloading</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:25:06 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I meant, it has more utilities than just downloading options</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:25:31 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I am not sure if they store all the Pubmed data inhouse or if it is accessed on the fly</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:25:50 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> I like their 'quick search' page - the library page is a bit off-putting</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:26:11 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> (PubMed is kept in-house btw)</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:26:19 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Jane, I totally agree with you. Everything is overwhelming</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:27:03 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> one needs to get familiar with the system</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:27:08 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> it's better than it used to be - last time i used it you went straight to that library page</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:27:30 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> if you're not familiar with what's in what database, you don't have a clue</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:27:46 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> absolutely. </font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:28:10 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I am familiar with only few of the DBs listed on that page</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:29:03 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> I've always found it too intimidating to use!</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:29:11 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> in the Pathways section for example, I had no idea what Ureaction Lreaction etc., meant</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:29:49 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I agree it is intimidating. But I think there are some features that we might want to copy</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:30:41 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> I don't think AmiGO could ever be that intimidating as we're only covering one database - they have so many databases to query that if you don't know what you're looking for, it's just overwhelming</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:30:42 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> As I said earlier, it is just not a tool for downloading. It aims to be comprehensive and take an user through a workflow</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:31:22 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I just realized it is almost 930AM</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:31:26 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> I got the NCBI search to work with the same file, do we still have time to give it try after the SRS? We need to change the database from Nucleotide to GSS.  The same file will work.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:32:05 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> hmmm...I am afraid we need to wrap up things soon.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:32:20 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Any questions so far?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:32:37 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> maybe email the file donghui and we can run it on our own?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:32:43 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> OK, here is the result page:</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:32:45 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> does anyone need to run off? otherwise I reckon keep going a bit longer as it's interesting to see the + / - points of these tools</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:32:46 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?WebEnv=0G02PfWyn2X5dk95ESMxI7GbRWFFh0iBk3fYAa8XkrrBMEp9kxYBdeeKCe2SEtZ7z2t7sfKTIA4AY%40D4497E80665820A0_0000SID&WebEnvRq=1&query_key=17&cmd=HistorySearch&db=nucgss">http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?WebEnv=0G02PfWyn2X5dk95ESMxI7GbRWFFh0iBk3fYAa8XkrrBMEp9kxYBdeeKCe2SEtZ7z2t7sfKTIA4AY%40D4497E80665820A0_0000SID&amp;WebEnvRq=1&amp;query_key=17&amp;cmd=HistorySearch&amp;db=nucgss</a></font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:32:48 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Sure. good idea Ben</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:33:24 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I am fine to continue</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(09:33:54 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> i'm not going anywhere</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:34:11 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> me too</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:34:14 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Please speak up if you *have to go*</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:34:28 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> alright, let's go back to NCBI for a few min</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:34:34 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> okay</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:34:50 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> the above link will direct you to the results page</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:34:55 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> I like the 'sort by' and 'send to' pull-down menus</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:35:51 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I must leave in 15-20 mins or so.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:35:58 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> The NCBI interface is very simple, however, like what happended, the query file has to be properly formatted (with GI or accession numeners0, which is not very flexible</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:36:03 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> but I do like to results page</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:36:17 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> Click the Display button</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:36:20 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I love the results page. It is simple</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:36:50 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> the results page is great, that's the nicest part of Entrez</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:37:12 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> so results page good, configurability bad</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:37:16 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I don't really care for it</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:38:55 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> the results page... that is.  It's fine I guess</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:40:03 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> any other comments?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(09:40:06 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> The one that frustrates me is that once you've selected an alternate display on the pull-down, it's not clear how to get back to your original results page.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(09:40:51 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> And the pull-down options on other displays isn't consistent</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:41:17 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> I agree with Eurie on the alt displays</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(09:41:18 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> for example, you don't get all the same options if you've selected &quot;graph&quot;</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:41:38 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> you are right, they are not consistent</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#469CD6">(09:41:44 AM) </font></font><font color="#469CD6"><font size="3">j-lo:</font></font><font size="3"> it's a bit buggy too - keeps giving me error messages</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:41:58 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> I also don't like the way that there's no 'confirm', it just automatically switches displays - that's annoying if you pick the wrong one</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(09:42:15 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> maybe we've confused the crap out of because we've got ip addresses around the world hitting the same page.  ;)</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:42:31 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> haha</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#88BE5A">(09:43:24 AM) </font></font><font color="#88BE5A"><font size="3">eurie:</font></font><font size="3"> but one principle that i like in general is if there are multiple pages or views or lots of categories, how do i get to a previous one without hitting the back button.</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:43:25 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> I actually like the No Confirm, you don't have to do that extra click</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:45:52 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> any more comments on NCBI?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:46:58 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> any questions on SRS?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:47:52 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> could I ask a couple of general questions if the summaries are finished?</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:48:05 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Go on GWG</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:48:19 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> these are for all the people who've looked at tools</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:48:58 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> did you need to have a clear goal in mind and background knowledge of the data source to be able to use the tool effectively?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:50:16 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> no</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:50:32 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> although &quot;what is effective&quot;</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:50:49 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> I guess 'to be able to use the tool' would be better</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:50:53 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I had some goal in mind I would say</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:51:03 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> otherwise I couldn't evaluate the results</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:51:29 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> were there specific features that made the tool easier to use?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:51:40 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> I liked &quot;count&quot; button</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:52:02 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> nothing in particular for SRS</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:52:06 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> and conversely, things that made it hard to use?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:52:12 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> too many options</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:52:26 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> SRS suffers from data overload</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7BCA99">(09:52:30 AM) </font></font><font color="#7BCA99"><font size="3">ben:</font></font><font size="3"> ok, I gotta go</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:52:40 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> thanks Ben!</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:52:41 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> have to know which specific database to search</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:52:44 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> see you. thanks Ben</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:52:55 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> shouldn't be a problem for amigo</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#7E9C4C">(09:53:03 AM) </font></font><font color="#7E9C4C"><font size="3">donghui:</font></font><font size="3"> I have to go too</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:53:13 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> shall we wrap up?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:53:20 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> yup, sounds good</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:53:29 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> before I finish, somebody please save the transcript</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(09:53:40 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> saved</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:53:50 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> I guess, I don't have any action items</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:54:12 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> quick! Let's think of some action items for Rama!</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:54:30 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> We all like some options in all these sites. Seems like Biomart is very flexible and usable.</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:54:39 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> NCBI has good results display</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:55:20 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> SRS kind of integrates tools to the data and tries to offer a complete utility</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:55:34 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Quick action items?</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:56:28 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3">  I don't know that there are any really...</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(09:56:34 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> if we missed anything, we could finish over email</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:56:44 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> okay. good. see you all in 2 weeks</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#621CE9">(09:56:54 AM) </font></font><font color="#621CE9"><font size="3">gwg:</font></font><font size="3"> see you then!</font><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:56:57 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> Seth, please email transcript to the WG</font><br><font size="2">(09:56:57 AM) </font><b><font size="3">gwg left the room (quit: Quit: Goodbye cruel world!).</font></b><br><font color="#9440B1"><font size="2">(09:56:58 AM) </font><font size="3">rama:</font></font><font size="3"> thanks</font><br><font size="2"><font color="#204a87">(09:57:08 AM) </font></font><font color="#204a87"><b><font size="3">sjcarbo1:</font></b></font><font size="3"></font><font size="3"> no problem--bye</font>

Latest revision as of 11:49, 9 April 2014

(08:38:13 AM) rama: shall we get started?
(08:38:21 AM) sjcarbo1: sorry--new client
(08:38:44 AM) sjcarbo1: yes
(08:39:39 AM) rama: we were going to review the download options at biomart, NCBI etc
(08:40:12 AM) rama: who wants to go first?
(08:40:17 AM) ben: I can go first
(08:40:22 AM) rama: Go for it Ben
(08:40:46 AM) ben: well - I looked at the Biomart 0.5 implementation at EBI
(08:41:17 AM) ben: this querying system allows you to basically construct your own "excel" table from various columns from various databases.
(08:41:33 AM) ben: There are probably millions of possible outputs.
(08:42:12 AM) ben: Basically you go through some javascript forms to set up the columns you want in your output, then you construct "filters" which limit the rows (so you don't get back the whole genome or whatever)
(08:42:30 AM) rama: How intuitive and easy are those forms?
(08:42:39 AM) ben: they suck
(08:42:48 AM) rama: ho
(08:42:56 AM) ben: but no fault of design - it's just an impossible task
(08:43:05 AM) ben: I mean there are HUNDREDS of columns
(08:43:11 AM) ben: but we won't have that problem
(08:43:32 AM) sjcarbo1: besides the volume, were there any other problems?
(08:43:37 AM) ben: I think for amigo purposes, we can probably just ship some set of columns. The filtering system is pretty good.
(08:43:51 AM) ben: No, I actualy like it for what it does
(08:44:01 AM) ben: other cool things:
(08:44:22 AM) ben: "count" button - so when you've assembled a query and possibly filters you can see how many rows you get back.
(08:44:40 AM) ben: Easy to get varaious options (HTML, CSV, TSV, XSL, XML)
(08:44:45 AM) ben: obv. I meant various
(08:45:05 AM) ben: can export to File, browser, or compressed file
(08:45:25 AM) ben: The ability to conjoin with other databases is pretty cool - but I wouldn't think of implementing this for us.
(08:46:27 AM) rama: you mean other databases like Taxon, OMIM, Pubmed
(08:46:28 AM) ben: oh, and they have a web service and a GUI button to ship you the XML you need to re-fetch the same query.
(08:46:53 AM) ben: no, sorry - I didn't explain scope. Biomart generally searches geneomes - human, rat, etc.
(08:47:04 AM) ben: if you link databases, you can combine queries.
(08:47:17 AM) ben: genome _databases_
(08:47:30 AM) rama: I see
(08:47:56 AM) j-lo: I've used Biomart before, and although it's not immediately intutitive, it is very cool because it's so configurable
(08:48:14 AM) sjcarbo1: how was the learning curve?
(08:48:36 AM) j-lo: not too bad - one session and I had a fairly good idea how to use
(08:48:37 AM) j-lo: it
(08:48:52 AM) ben: it's irrelvant - right?
(08:49:09 AM) ben: we are not going to actually USE biomart, just rip off it's interfaces (if we like them)
(08:49:24 AM) sjcarbo1: thus the learning curve
(08:49:45 AM) sjcarbo1: where stuff is, how to get to things
(08:49:52 AM) eurie: yeah, i think the hardest thing was understanding what all the labels meant but I think if we label things on the interface appropriately, this should be easier.
(08:50:02 AM) rama: even to get the general idea of what it can do
(08:50:42 AM) j-lo: I agree with Eurie - it's figuring out what data are in the different columns that makes it tricky
(08:51:00 AM) j-lo: if we can make that intuitive we'd be laughing
(08:51:26 AM) ben: I think we would be better served by giving fewer options and just defaulting the output to more columsn
(08:51:47 AM) j-lo: yeah - our database is much simpler so we could do that
(08:52:13 AM) eurie: Also, alluding to the wizard vs. single page discussion over email, the filtering options (which data you want to restrict by) are all on one page. which helps you see everything at once.
(08:52:20 AM) ben: biomart is like that because it has to be generic - you can interface any database to it, so obviuosly it doesn't know what colunms to show.
(08:52:35 AM) ben: although in principal you could "hardwire" biomart ... but I digress
(08:53:32 AM) eurie: I think the older biomart implementation was a wizard - multi page step through.
(08:54:29 AM) gwg: the ideal implementation would be something which allowed the more advanced users to configure the results to their liking, but which wouldn't alienate newbies by being too complex
(08:54:29 AM) rama left the room (quit: Read error: Connection reset by peer).
(08:55:29 AM) eurie: oops, we lost our chair
(08:55:51 AM) gwg: perhaps the default should be simple, so that people aren't overwhelmed by huge amounts of data
(08:56:01 AM) rama [rama@c-24-7-125-169.hsd1.ca.comcast.net] entered the room.
(08:56:11 AM) rama: sorry, i got disconnected
(08:56:22 AM) ben: I guess to break it down:
(08:56:42 AM) ben: row selection good. column selection bad.
(08:56:55 AM) rama: Can somebody save the transcript for me ( I lost parts of it).
(08:57:02 AM) ben: maybe in blocks it's OK -
(08:57:21 AM) ben: we assume people want gene_products -> associations
(08:57:31 AM) gwg: for example, I think that the a
(08:57:35 AM) gwg: ooops, sorry
(08:57:44 AM) ben: +/- species +/- evidence (?!?) +/- references
(08:57:50 AM) sjcarbo1: (rama--I'll save and send what I have)
(08:57:59 AM) ben: oh, we should also move on to another interface
(08:58:10 AM) rama: I was just about to say that Ben
(08:58:19 AM) rama: Donghui, do you want to go?
(08:58:37 AM) donghui: sure
(08:59:16 AM) donghui: just a second
(09:00:16 AM) donghui: <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/batchentrez.cgi?db=Nucleotide">http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/batchentrez.cgi?db=Nucleotide</a>
(09:00:32 AM) donghui: first, The Batch Search has now been combined with the ?regular? Entrez Search: ?You will need Batch Entrez now only to upload a file of GI or accession numbers for an Entrez search. You can do all other large searches directly within Entrez.?
(09:01:22 AM) donghui: I don't know exactly how to do a large search directly within entrez
(09:01:34 AM) donghui: So i tried the Batch search
(09:02:07 AM) donghui: The nicest part of Entrez is its result display: very flexible. You can filter the results in all kinds of ways.
(09:02:07 AM) donghui: You can choose to display different parts of the gene information: Brief, Summary, Sequence in different format etc.
(09:02:07 AM) donghui: You can specify the number of hits to display per page as well as sort results accession and Taxonomy ID.
(09:02:07 AM) donghui: It allows user to send the result to various destinations: as txt, as a file, printer or clipboard.
(09:03:11 AM) donghui: the other nice feature is that Entrez allows users to save search history for 8 hrs, which is useful
(09:04:55 AM) donghui: if you want to try the search you can put the following GI/accession numbers into a txt file:
(09:05:00 AM) donghui: The nicest part of Entrez is its result display: very flexible. You can filter the results in all kinds of ways.
(09:05:00 AM) donghui: You can choose to display different parts of the gene information: Brief, Summary, Sequence in different format etc.
(09:05:00 AM) donghui: You can specify the number of hits to display per page as well as sort results accession and Taxonomy ID.
(09:05:00 AM) donghui: It allows user to send the result to various destinations: as txt, as a file, printer or clipboard.
(09:05:04 AM) donghui: sorry
(09:05:13 AM) donghui: AL436771
(09:05:14 AM) donghui: AL423804
(09:05:14 AM) donghui: AL422882
(09:05:14 AM) donghui: CZ193470
(09:05:14 AM) donghui: DQ052056
(09:05:16 AM) donghui: DQ052055
(09:06:54 AM) rama: are there links and tools relevant to your search results?
(09:07:26 AM) donghui: what do you mean by tools?
(09:07:42 AM) rama: for example ClustalW to see alignment?
(09:08:09 AM) donghui: I did not see that
(09:08:38 AM) j-lo: I couldn't get it to work - says 'No query #1 in history for database nucleotide'
(09:09:09 AM) donghui: that's strange, it happened to me too.
(09:10:39 AM) j-lo: anyone else get it to work?
(09:10:57 AM) rama: Donghui, for batch download do you always need GI/accession #s or gene names will work?
(09:13:09 AM) rama: I am going to move on
(09:13:14 AM) rama: to SRS
(09:13:18 AM) donghui: yes, that's pain
(09:13:49 AM) donghui: the file can only contain GI or accession numbers, I have tried these numbers when I tested it
(09:14:30 AM) rama: thanks DOnghui.
(09:14:43 AM) donghui: if I want to retrieve sequences for Arabidopsis genes and I only know the Arabidopsis locus identifier, these identifiers have to be converted to GI or accerssion numbers first
(09:15:44 AM) rama: that is a pain.
(09:16:03 AM) rama: the take home is we can look at their results page for display ideas
(09:16:05 AM) rama: ?
(09:16:37 AM) rama: <a href="http://srs.ebi.ac.uk/">http://srs.ebi.ac.uk/</a>
(09:16:51 AM) rama: Anybody, any questions on NCBI?
(09:17:52 AM) rama: Okay...moving on. Please visit SRS at the above URL
(09:18:43 AM) rama: Few things I liked- They have a whole list of Databases that one can choose from. They include Pubmed, Taxon, etc (databases are not limited to what is maintained at EBI)
(09:19:57 AM) rama: 2) Views- you can control what you want to see, what you want hyperlinked. For example, for a pubmed citation, you can view only the PMID and not the other details.
(09:20:11 AM) rama: 3) Tools relevant to your search results
(09:20:52 AM) rama: If you have a list of proteins as output, it suggests tools that can be used to analyze that list further. CLustalW for example. They have a whole suite of tools
(09:21:41 AM) rama: 4) All your queries are saved in the 'Projects' link on the top tool bar.
(09:22:50 AM) rama: First time I saw the interface it was overwhelming (like Biomart), but then it has lots of features
(09:23:10 AM) eurie: Rama, how long are your queries saved? Just for that session?
(09:23:29 AM) rama: i think just for that session.
(09:24:34 AM) rama: it is more than a tool for downloading
(09:25:06 AM) rama: I meant, it has more utilities than just downloading options
(09:25:31 AM) rama: I am not sure if they store all the Pubmed data inhouse or if it is accessed on the fly
(09:25:50 AM) j-lo: I like their 'quick search' page - the library page is a bit off-putting
(09:26:11 AM) j-lo: (PubMed is kept in-house btw)
(09:26:19 AM) rama: Jane, I totally agree with you. Everything is overwhelming
(09:27:03 AM) rama: one needs to get familiar with the system
(09:27:08 AM) j-lo: it's better than it used to be - last time i used it you went straight to that library page
(09:27:30 AM) j-lo: if you're not familiar with what's in what database, you don't have a clue
(09:27:46 AM) rama: absolutely.
(09:28:10 AM) rama: I am familiar with only few of the DBs listed on that page
(09:29:03 AM) gwg: I've always found it too intimidating to use!
(09:29:11 AM) rama: in the Pathways section for example, I had no idea what Ureaction Lreaction etc., meant
(09:29:49 AM) rama: I agree it is intimidating. But I think there are some features that we might want to copy
(09:30:41 AM) gwg: I don't think AmiGO could ever be that intimidating as we're only covering one database - they have so many databases to query that if you don't know what you're looking for, it's just overwhelming
(09:30:42 AM) rama: As I said earlier, it is just not a tool for downloading. It aims to be comprehensive and take an user through a workflow
(09:31:22 AM) rama: I just realized it is almost 930AM
(09:31:26 AM) donghui: I got the NCBI search to work with the same file, do we still have time to give it try after the SRS? We need to change the database from Nucleotide to GSS. The same file will work.
(09:32:05 AM) rama: hmmm...I am afraid we need to wrap up things soon.
(09:32:20 AM) rama: Any questions so far?
(09:32:37 AM) ben: maybe email the file donghui and we can run it on our own?
(09:32:43 AM) donghui: OK, here is the result page:
(09:32:45 AM) gwg: does anyone need to run off? otherwise I reckon keep going a bit longer as it's interesting to see the + / - points of these tools
(09:32:46 AM) donghui: <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?WebEnv=0G02PfWyn2X5dk95ESMxI7GbRWFFh0iBk3fYAa8XkrrBMEp9kxYBdeeKCe2SEtZ7z2t7sfKTIA4AY%40D4497E80665820A0_0000SID&WebEnvRq=1&query_key=17&cmd=HistorySearch&db=nucgss">http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?WebEnv=0G02PfWyn2X5dk95ESMxI7GbRWFFh0iBk3fYAa8XkrrBMEp9kxYBdeeKCe2SEtZ7z2t7sfKTIA4AY%40D4497E80665820A0_0000SID&WebEnvRq=1&query_key=17&cmd=HistorySearch&db=nucgss</a>
(09:32:48 AM) rama: Sure. good idea Ben
(09:33:24 AM) rama: I am fine to continue
(09:33:54 AM) sjcarbo1: i'm not going anywhere
(09:34:11 AM) j-lo: me too
(09:34:14 AM) rama: Please speak up if you *have to go*
(09:34:28 AM) donghui: alright, let's go back to NCBI for a few min
(09:34:34 AM) rama: okay
(09:34:50 AM) donghui: the above link will direct you to the results page
(09:34:55 AM) j-lo: I like the 'sort by' and 'send to' pull-down menus
(09:35:51 AM) ben: I must leave in 15-20 mins or so.
(09:35:58 AM) donghui: The NCBI interface is very simple, however, like what happended, the query file has to be properly formatted (with GI or accession numeners0, which is not very flexible
(09:36:03 AM) donghui: but I do like to results page
(09:36:17 AM) donghui: Click the Display button
(09:36:20 AM) rama: I love the results page. It is simple
(09:36:50 AM) donghui: the results page is great, that's the nicest part of Entrez
(09:37:12 AM) j-lo: so results page good, configurability bad
(09:37:16 AM) ben: I don't really care for it
(09:38:55 AM) ben: the results page... that is. It's fine I guess
(09:40:03 AM) rama: any other comments?
(09:40:06 AM) eurie: The one that frustrates me is that once you've selected an alternate display on the pull-down, it's not clear how to get back to your original results page.
(09:40:51 AM) eurie: And the pull-down options on other displays isn't consistent
(09:41:17 AM) gwg: I agree with Eurie on the alt displays
(09:41:18 AM) eurie: for example, you don't get all the same options if you've selected "graph"
(09:41:38 AM) donghui: you are right, they are not consistent
(09:41:44 AM) j-lo: it's a bit buggy too - keeps giving me error messages
(09:41:58 AM) gwg: I also don't like the way that there's no 'confirm', it just automatically switches displays - that's annoying if you pick the wrong one
(09:42:15 AM) eurie: maybe we've confused the crap out of because we've got ip addresses around the world hitting the same page.  ;)
(09:42:31 AM) rama: haha
(09:43:24 AM) eurie: but one principle that i like in general is if there are multiple pages or views or lots of categories, how do i get to a previous one without hitting the back button.
(09:43:25 AM) donghui: I actually like the No Confirm, you don't have to do that extra click
(09:45:52 AM) rama: any more comments on NCBI?
(09:46:58 AM) rama: any questions on SRS?
(09:47:52 AM) gwg: could I ask a couple of general questions if the summaries are finished?
(09:48:05 AM) rama: Go on GWG
(09:48:19 AM) gwg: these are for all the people who've looked at tools
(09:48:58 AM) gwg: did you need to have a clear goal in mind and background knowledge of the data source to be able to use the tool effectively?
(09:50:16 AM) ben: no
(09:50:32 AM) ben: although "what is effective"
(09:50:49 AM) gwg: I guess 'to be able to use the tool' would be better
(09:50:53 AM) rama: I had some goal in mind I would say
(09:51:03 AM) rama: otherwise I couldn't evaluate the results
(09:51:29 AM) gwg: were there specific features that made the tool easier to use?
(09:51:40 AM) ben: I liked "count" button
(09:52:02 AM) rama: nothing in particular for SRS
(09:52:06 AM) gwg: and conversely, things that made it hard to use?
(09:52:12 AM) ben: too many options
(09:52:26 AM) rama: SRS suffers from data overload
(09:52:30 AM) ben: ok, I gotta go
(09:52:40 AM) gwg: thanks Ben!
(09:52:41 AM) donghui: have to know which specific database to search
(09:52:44 AM) rama: see you. thanks Ben
(09:52:55 AM) donghui: shouldn't be a problem for amigo
(09:53:03 AM) donghui: I have to go too
(09:53:13 AM) rama: shall we wrap up?
(09:53:20 AM) gwg: yup, sounds good
(09:53:29 AM) rama: before I finish, somebody please save the transcript
(09:53:40 AM) sjcarbo1: saved
(09:53:50 AM) rama: I guess, I don't have any action items
(09:54:12 AM) gwg: quick! Let's think of some action items for Rama!
(09:54:30 AM) rama: We all like some options in all these sites. Seems like Biomart is very flexible and usable.
(09:54:39 AM) rama: NCBI has good results display
(09:55:20 AM) rama: SRS kind of integrates tools to the data and tries to offer a complete utility
(09:55:34 AM) rama: Quick action items?
(09:56:28 AM) gwg: I don't know that there are any really...
(09:56:34 AM) sjcarbo1: if we missed anything, we could finish over email
(09:56:44 AM) rama: okay. good. see you all in 2 weeks
(09:56:54 AM) gwg: see you then!
(09:56:57 AM) rama: Seth, please email transcript to the WG
(09:56:57 AM) gwg left the room (quit: Quit: Goodbye cruel world!).
(09:56:58 AM) rama: thanks
(09:57:08 AM) sjcarbo1: no problem--bye