GO-CAM Conference Call - 2019-01-15: Difference between revisions

From GO Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
mNo edit summary
 
(30 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
= Meeting URL =
= Meeting URL =
*https://stanford.zoom.us/j/976175422
*Please consult the GO calendar


= Agenda =
= Agenda =
Line 14: Line 14:
****documentation
****documentation
**Continued discussion of modeling questions
**Continued discussion of modeling questions
***Annotation of protein complexes and their respective members
****When to annotate to a complex vs making each individual MF just 'part of' the same process?
****[https://docs.google.com/document/d/1MssCGE45H3IFHvVq9y7BUo9Brw5bIwXnOSl7efPf1fI/edit Nuclear Pores Regulate Muscle Development and Maintenance by Assembling a Localized Mef2C Complex]
***Instance-level representation
****When to annotate to the same 'instance' of a biological process vs different 'instances'?
****Implications for curator workflow
***Modeling from multiple species
****Creating a model for one species when the evidence derives from experiments in multiple species
****Creating models for processes that involve more than one species
**Import of Reactome pathways
**Import of Reactome pathways
**Generation and use of templates
***Glycolysis
***MAPK
***BMP
***Wnt
***ER-UPR
***GPI synthesis
***Size limitations and delineation of 'models'
****How to 'stitch' or connect large models in a consistent manner that allows us to represent dependencies (upstream, downstream) in a biologically meaningful way that is also computationally amenable
**Model manipulation
***Generation and use of templates
***Merging models
***Copying and/or re-using annotations


= Minutes =
= Minutes =
*On call:
*On call: Barbara, Chris, David, Dustin, Edith, Elena, Giulia, Harold, Helen, Kevin M, Kimberly, Laurent-Philippe, Marie-Claire, Paul T., Petra, Rob, Ruth, Sabrina, Seth, Stacia, Suzi A


*Import of whole genomes
**David, Kimberly, and the software team will have a f2f meeting to work on importing the first two whole genome's worth of annotation for WormBase and MGI
**Will report back on a future call - decisions made, any problems that arose, etc.
**For converting annotation extensions, Paul T. and Dustin have done some preliminary work which groups should look at on the corresponding wiki page:
***http://wiki.geneontology.org/index.php/Extensions2GO-CAM
***has_regulation_target is one of the most commonly used extension relations and it is not used in GO-CAM
****Its translation may depend on the particular GO term with which it was used.
**Model manipulation will likely be key for dealing with whole genome's worth of annotation imports and we will need to gather explicit requirements for that


*Continued discussion of modeling questions
**Will spend time this year discussing annotation of protein complexes, their members, and associated activities
**Will also discussion 'instance' level representation of biological processes and implications for workflow
***[https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/119pVRxuGZK9keJaVDZk2Z4kzNoysuQwZ Google folder for capturing examples for discussion of instance-level representation]
**Models involving, or based on experiments in, multiple species need to be discussed, as well


*Import of Reactome pathways
**Smaller working group will be examining import of Reactome pathways into GO-CAMs
**Specific pathways have been chosen based on preliminary work already done, e.g. glycolysis and signaling, ER-UPR
**This work should, and already has been, very informative for how we model things in GO-CAM
**Reactome imports also raises issues about model size and delineating and linking smaller models that are causally related


*GO-CAM display
**Petra has shown some of the dicty community GO-CAM models
**Reaction was positive, but we need to spend more time working on various display options, making people aware of what APIs already exist for grabbing data for display, etc.
**Whole genome import is currently the top priority, but intuitive, user friendly display of models is very important and will be the subject of future work








 
[[Category: GO-CAM]]
 
 
 
 
 
 
[[Category: Annotation]] [[Category:Working Groups]]

Latest revision as of 06:18, 12 April 2019

Meeting URL

  • Please consult the GO calendar

Agenda

  • From 2019-01-07 annotation conference call:
    • Import of whole genomes
      • Working meeting at Berkeley the end of this month
      • WormBase and MGI will be the first genome annotation sets to be imported
        • gp2term relations
        • evidence and annotation extensions
        • search, display, editing
        • gpad output
        • overall data flow
        • documentation
    • Continued discussion of modeling questions
      • Annotation of protein complexes and their respective members
      • Instance-level representation
        • When to annotate to the same 'instance' of a biological process vs different 'instances'?
        • Implications for curator workflow
      • Modeling from multiple species
        • Creating a model for one species when the evidence derives from experiments in multiple species
        • Creating models for processes that involve more than one species
    • Import of Reactome pathways
      • Glycolysis
      • MAPK
      • BMP
      • Wnt
      • ER-UPR
      • GPI synthesis
      • Size limitations and delineation of 'models'
        • How to 'stitch' or connect large models in a consistent manner that allows us to represent dependencies (upstream, downstream) in a biologically meaningful way that is also computationally amenable
    • Model manipulation
      • Generation and use of templates
      • Merging models
      • Copying and/or re-using annotations

Minutes

  • On call: Barbara, Chris, David, Dustin, Edith, Elena, Giulia, Harold, Helen, Kevin M, Kimberly, Laurent-Philippe, Marie-Claire, Paul T., Petra, Rob, Ruth, Sabrina, Seth, Stacia, Suzi A
  • Import of whole genomes
    • David, Kimberly, and the software team will have a f2f meeting to work on importing the first two whole genome's worth of annotation for WormBase and MGI
    • Will report back on a future call - decisions made, any problems that arose, etc.
    • For converting annotation extensions, Paul T. and Dustin have done some preliminary work which groups should look at on the corresponding wiki page:
    • Model manipulation will likely be key for dealing with whole genome's worth of annotation imports and we will need to gather explicit requirements for that
  • Continued discussion of modeling questions
  • Import of Reactome pathways
    • Smaller working group will be examining import of Reactome pathways into GO-CAMs
    • Specific pathways have been chosen based on preliminary work already done, e.g. glycolysis and signaling, ER-UPR
    • This work should, and already has been, very informative for how we model things in GO-CAM
    • Reactome imports also raises issues about model size and delineating and linking smaller models that are causally related
  • GO-CAM display
    • Petra has shown some of the dicty community GO-CAM models
    • Reaction was positive, but we need to spend more time working on various display options, making people aware of what APIs already exist for grabbing data for display, etc.
    • Whole genome import is currently the top priority, but intuitive, user friendly display of models is very important and will be the subject of future work