Taxon-GO Checks and Commentary - Response to GOA - Part 5

From GO Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
The printable version is no longer supported and may have rendering errors. Please update your browser bookmarks and please use the default browser print function instead.

Line 7: TAXON RULE INCORRECT THIS TERM SHOULD INCLUDE VIRUSES GO:0019064 "viral envelope fusion with host membrane" only_in NCBITaxon:131567 "cellular organisms" :: Swiss-Prot P36334 S GO:0019064 PMID:11162792 TAS P protein NCBITaxon:31631 20030508 UniProtKB

Q/ Should viral envelope fusion with host membrane really be an is_a to cellular process? Viral gene products can be annotated to this.

Line 19: TAXON RULE INCORRECT EUGELA CONTAIN CHLOROPLASTS AND cytochrome b6f complex GO:0009775 "photosynthetic electron transport in cytochrome b6/f" only_in ID:0000000 "Viridiplantae or Bacteria" :: Swiss-Prot P31480 petB GO:0009775 PMID:12837550 NAS P protein NCBITaxon:3039 20031120 UniProtKB

A/ New union term made and rule corrected.

Line 21: TAXON RULE INCORRECT EUGELA CONTAIN CHLOROPLASTS GO:0009507 "chloroplast" only_in NCBITaxon:33090 "Viridiplantae" :: Swiss-Prot P83687 PSBP GO:0009507 PMID:12837550 IDA C protein NCBITaxon:3039 20031120 UniProtKB

A/ New union term made for Viridiplantae and Euglenozoa.

Line 22: TAXON RULE INCORRECT EUGELA CONTAIN CHLOROPLASTS GO:0009507 "chloroplast" only_in NCBITaxon:33090 "Viridiplantae" :: Swiss-Prot Q8GZR2 petA GO:0009507 PMID:12837550 IDA C protein NCBITaxon:3039 20031120 UniProtKB Line 23: TAXON RULE INCORRECT EUGELA CONTAIN CHLOROPLASTS GO:0009507 "chloroplast" only_in NCBITaxon:33090 "Viridiplantae" :: Swiss-Prot P83688 P83688 GO:0009507 PMID:12837550 IDA C protein NCBITaxon:3039 20031120 UniProtKB

A/ As above.

Line 25: TAXON RULE INCORRECT EUGELA CONTAIN CHLOROPLASTS AND cytochrome b6f complex GO:0009512 "cytochrome b6f complex" only_in JD:0000002 "Viridiplantae or Cyanobacteria" :: Swiss-Prot Q84TU6 petD GO:0009512 PMID:12837550 IDA C protein NCBITaxon:3039 20040507 UniProtKB

A/ Changed to Viridiplantae or bacteria or Euglenozoa.

Line 26: TAXON RULE INCORRECT EUGELA CONTAIN CHLOROPLASTS AND cytochrome b6f complex GO:0009512 "cytochrome b6f complex" only_in JD:0000002 "Viridiplantae or Cyanobacteria" :: Swiss-Prot P31480 petB GO:0009512 PMID:12837550 IDA C protein NCBITaxon:3039 20031120 UniProtKB

A/ As above.

Line 36: TAXON RULE INCORRECT. (DEF OF GO TERM INCLUDES CYANOBACTERIUM) GO:0030089 "phycobilisome" only_in NCBITaxon:2759 "Eukaryota" :: Swiss-Prot Q54714 cpcB GO:0030089 PMID:14730074 IDA C protein NCBITaxon:1148 20050613 UniProtKB

A/ This rule is not present. Perhaps it was previously corrected.

Line 37: TAXON RULE INCORRECT. (DEF OF GO TERM INCLUDES CYANOBACTERIUM) GO:0030089 "phycobilisome" only_in NCBITaxon:2759 "Eukaryota" :: Swiss-Prot Q54715 cpcA GO:0030089 PMID:14730074 IDA C protein NCBITaxon:1148 20050613 UniProtKB

A/ As above.

Line 38: TAXON RULE INCORRECT. (DEF OF GO TERM INCLUDES CYANOBACTERIUM) GO:0030089 "phycobilisome" only_in NCBITaxon:2759 "Eukaryota" :: Swiss-Prot Q01951 apcA GO:0030089 PMID:14730074 IDA C protein NCBITaxon:1148 20050613 UniProtKB

A/ As above.

Line 49: TAXON RULE INCORRECT: GO:0006260 "DNA replication" only_in NCBITaxon:131567 "cellular organisms" :: TrEMBL O00529 O00529 GO:0006260 GO_REF:0000029 NAS P protein NCBITaxon:333760 20021106 UniProtKB

A/ This is a problem in the graph. We need generic and cellular versions of DNA replication.

Line 52: TAXON RULE INCORRECT. (annotation to a major plant storage protein) GO:0045735 "nutrient reservoir activity" only_in NCBITaxon:88770 "Panarthropoda" :: Swiss-Prot Q9XHP1 Q9XHP1 GO:0045735 PMID:10606554 NAS F protein NCBITaxon:4182 20051104 UniProtKB

A/ This rule appears to be gone already.

Line 53: TAXON RULE INCORRECT. (annotation to a major plant storage protein) GO:0045735 "nutrient reservoir activity" only_in NCBITaxon:88770 "Panarthropoda" :: Swiss-Prot Q9SPL3 AMP2-3 GO:0045735 PMID:10571855 NAS F protein NCBITaxon:60698 20060904 UniProtKB

A/ As above.

Line 54: TAXON RULE INCORRECT. (annotation to a major plant storage protein)GO:0045735 "nutrient reservoir activity" only_in NCBITaxon:88770 "Panarthropoda" :: Swiss-Prot Q9XHP0 Q9XHP0 GO:0045735 PMID:10606554 NAS F protein NCBITaxon:4182 20051104 UniProtKB

A/ As above.

Line 55: TAXON RULE INCORRECT. (annotation to a major plant storage protein) GO:0045735 "nutrient reservoir activity" only_in NCBITaxon:88770 "Panarthropoda" :: Swiss-Prot Q39649 Q39649 GO:0045735 PMID:8275099 TAS F protein NCBITaxon:3661 20050516 UniProtKB

A/ As above.

Line 82: TAXON RULE INCORRECT GO:0008274 "gamma-tubulin ring complex" only_in NCBITaxon:4751 "Fungi" :: Swiss-Prot Q95K09 TUBGCP5 GO:0008274 PMID:11694571 ISS UniProtKB:Q96RT8 C protein NCBITaxon:9541 20041006 UniProtKB

A/ Rule deleted.

Line 84: TAXON RULE INCORRECT GO:0008274 "gamma-tubulin ring complex" only_in NCBITaxon:4751 "Fungi" :: Swiss-Prot Q9GKK8 BRCA1 GO:0008274 PMID:12214252 NAS C protein NCBITaxon:9598 20021218 UniProtKB

A/ Rule deleted.

Line 97: TAXON RULE INCORRECT.GO:0042475 "odontogenesis of dentine-containing tooth" only_in NCBITaxon:33317 "Protostomia" :: MGI MGI:104659 Dll1 GO:0042475 MGI:MGI:1327472|PMID:9882480 NAS P gene NCBITaxon:10090 20021218 UniProtKB

A/ Bumped this up to Chordata from the current position under Vertebrate to see if that solves the problem.

Line 98: TAXON RULE INCORRECT.GO:0042476 "odontogenesis" only_in NCBITaxon:33317 "Protostomia" :: MGI MGI:1914505 Zfp422 GO:0042476 MGI:MGI:2449683|PMID:12489153 NAS P gene NCBITaxon:10090 20040226 UniProtKB

A/ Deleted rule

Line 99: TAXON RULE INCORRECT.GO:0042476 "odontogenesis" only_in NCBITaxon:33317 "Protostomia" :: RGD 620229 Zfp422 GO:0042476 RGD:14706453 NAS P gene NCBITaxon:10116 20040226 UniProtKB

A/ Deleted rule.

Ontology Corrections

DNA Replication

Line 49: TAXON RULE INCORRECT: GO:0006260 "DNA replication" only_in NCBITaxon:131567 "cellular organisms" :: TrEMBL O00529 O00529 GO:0006260 GO_REF:0000029 NAS P protein NCBITaxon:333760 20021106 UniProtKB

A/ This is a problem in the graph. We need generic and cellular versions of DNA replication.

Terms created:

> id: GO:0055132
> name: cellular DNA metabolic process

> id: GO:0055133
> name: cellular DNA replication

> id: GO:0055134
> name: cellular nucleobase, nucleoside, nucleotide and nucleic acid metabolic process
 


Viral annotations to non-cellular terms with cellular ancestors

Line 7: TAXON RULE INCORRECT THIS TERM SHOULD INCLUDE VIRUSES GO:0019064 "viral envelope fusion with host membrane" only_in NCBITaxon:131567 "cellular organisms" :: Swiss-Prot P36334 S GO:0019064 PMID:11162792 TAS P protein NCBITaxon:31631 20030508 UniProtKB

Q/ Should viral envelope fusion with host membrane really be an is_a to cellular process? Viral gene products can be annotated to this.

- Removed the rule that locomotion (GO:0040011) is only in cellular organisms.

- Removed link from membrane organization (GO:0016044) to cellular process.

Viruses and response to stimulus

GO:0052085 "negative regulation by symbiont of host T-cell mediated immune response" only_in NCBITaxon:131567 "cellular organisms"

From checking with Jane it appears that a symbiont can also be a virus, so this taxon rule should be removed

A/

I have removed this rule:

[Term]
id: GO:0050896
name: response to stimulus
relationship: only_in_taxon NCBITaxon:131567 ! cellular organisms

This does not hold true as viruses also respond to the stimuli produced by their hosts.

For similar reasons I have removed these links:

[Term] id: GO:0051179 name: localization relationship: only_in_taxon NCBITaxon:131567 ! cellular organisms

[Term] id: GO:0032502 name: developmental process relationship: only_in_taxon NCBITaxon:131567 ! cellular organisms

Cellular process only_in_taxon cellular organisms?

id: GO:0009987
name: cellular process
relationship: only_in_taxon NCBITaxon:131567 ! cellular organisms

I have removed this rule for the reasons stated in my proposal.